What is the difference between Actual Cash Value and Replacment Cost and which one is best for you?

October 1, 2026

Imagine this situation.
About five years ago, you bought a new flat screen TV for over $1,000. Then after a thunderstorm rolls through, it won’t turn on. It’s destroyed. So, you file a claim with your insurance company, but you’re left confused when your settlement check is less than $1,000. After all, that’s what you paid for the TV, right? It all comes down to the type of contents coverage you’ve selected in your homeowners insurance policy: actual cash value or replacement cost value. But you can avoid this confusing situation by reviewing your coverage options with your independent insurance agent ahead of time. Check out our info about actual cash value and replacement cost to help you understand the difference so you can choose the right coverage for your home insurance policy

.

ACTUAL CASH VALUE:
*What it's worth at the time the loss occurs, sitting in your living room.
*What you could sell it for at a yard sale, used.
*Replacement cost minus depreciation.
*This settlement amount will be lower.
   New TV Worth $1,000, Depreciation minus $400, Your check $600.

REPLACEMENT COST:
*What it's worth at the time the loss occurs, sitting on a showroom floor.
*What you could buy it for at a store, new.
*this does not take into account any depreciation.
*This settlement amount will be higher.
    New TV worth $1,000, Your check $1,000

In most claims the adjuster may pay out depreciated value first and then pay the difference as you replace the items.

Quote

Get a Quote

At John Dawson Associates, securing your future is simple. Ready to protect what matters? Contact us for a quick quote!

Chat With Us

Chat With Us

Chat with Kelly to gather your info, helping our agents find the best carriers and quotes.

Call

Call Us

For any inquiries or support, feel free to reach out to us at any time. We're here to assist you!

Note

Send Us a Message

Send a message with your name, email, phone number, and the insurance type you're seeking.

Personal Insurance

Personal Insurance

From auto and homeowners to renters and umbrella policies, we help protect your family and property. Let’s find coverage that fits your life.

Business Insurance

Commercial Insurance

We customize policies for your industry's risks, like general liability and workers' comp, ensuring you can run your business worry-free.

Share this article

Recent Posts

Hand placing a pink umbrella over small wooden figures on a table
By John Dawson Associates • October 9, 2026
Columbus families with homes, cars, and assets need more liability coverage than standard policies provide. Learn how umbrella insurance protects your financial future.
Worker in red hard hat holding a piggy bank and pointing, standing outdoors near houses and a car.
By John Dawson Associates • October 9, 2026
Ohio's workers' compensation system is unique in the U.S. Learn how the BWC works, when you can use private carriers, and what it means for your business costs.
Person working at a sunlit desk with laptop, notebook, coffee, and calculator
By John Dawson Associates • October 9, 2026
Ohio business owners: Learn how PEOs compare to traditional payroll services, what it means for workers' comp, and which option saves you money and headaches.